All Day Anal: The Best Butt Plugs To Wear All Day – 2019 Review

Butt plugs are sexy toys inserted into the rectum for pleasurable pressure and arousal. There’s been some buzz about the internet about wearing a butt plug for longer than play time. People are wearing them around the house or while out and about -- even all day.

The question is: Can you wear a butt plug all day? Is it safe? Most of all, why would a person want to? For all the juicy details on this kinky little secret, read on.

Comparison Chart for the Best All Day Butt Plugs


Lovehoney Extra Petite Butt Plug

  • 2.75" of insertable length and is designed with a flared base
  • Constructed from body-safe silicone, which is also easy to clean
  • Extra petite design makes it perfect for beginners
View Latest Price

Jelly Rancher Butt Plug

  • 3" of insertable length and features a flared base
  • Designed with smooth, TPE material
  • Features a suction cup base for hands-free fun
View Latest Price

Doc Johnson Naughty Butt Plug

  • 3" of insertable length and is designed with a flared base for added safety
  • Made from body-safe silicone and is 100% waterproof
  • T-bar base and long neck makes it great for all day wear
View Latest Price

Roll Play Butt Plug

  • 3" of insertable length and suction cup base
  • Constructed of silicone and is perfect for beginners
  • Features an free-moving internal ball for added fun
View Latest Price

Lovehoney Booty Buddy

  • 4" of insertable length and T-bar base makes it perfect for P-spot pleasure
  • Sleek and smooth silicone design
  • Great for all experience levels and can be used over an extended period of time
View Latest Price

Is it Safe to Wear a Butt Plug All Day?


First, your most burning question: Why would you want to wear a butt plug all day? Well, because it feels good.

People who wear their plugs outside of the bedroom report:

  • Constant pleasurable feeling of fullness and pressure (especially on the prostate)
  • Additional stimulation when plug rocks back and forth a bit as they move
  • A sensual haze over their daily activities
  • Being warmed up all day and ready to go right away at night


Despite this glowing endorsement, many doctors and even some avid ass play addicts discourage lengthy butt plug wear.

The reasons they cite are anatomical.

  • The lining of the rectum is very delicate and contains lots of important blood vessels. When you stick something in there, it can restrict blood flow and lead to tissue damage and ulceration.
  • An added risk is that you don’t have pain receptors beyond the first inch or so inside your rectum. You could be doing damage and not even know it.

Who's wearing a plug in this picture? Someone's having fun.

Which Butt Plugs Can be Worn All Day?

Short and Narrow

Safest and most comfortable butt plugs for all-day wear are probably going to be shorter and have a narrow neck.

The anal entry isn’t used to being stretched out indefinitely, so a skinny neck is the best bet. 

Wide and Flat End

If you plan to sit down, you probably want the wide end of your plug to be a low profile and fit snuggly against your body.

Look for plugs with flat or body contoured shape as opposed to one with a handle, ring or button.

Flexible and Bendy

Since you are going to be moving around with your plug in, it’s going to be more comfortable to have a plug that moves and bends with you.

Flexible plugs of jelly or silicone are also going to be less likely than glass or metal to cause damage (Remember! You don’t have pain receptors after the first inch!). 

Find a plug that bends when you bend, and moves when you move. 

Review of the Best Butt Plugs to Wear All Day

Alright, so you want to put some extra spring your booty as you go about your day. Let’s review some plug options for all-day wear.

1. Classic Silicone Extra Petite Beginner's Butt Plug



  • Silicone
  • Flat base
  • Short length / Narrow neck


  • Might be too small for significant stimulation
  • water-based lube will need to be used and reapplied

This Lovehoney Classic Silicone Extra Petite butt plug is a great starter plug for longer term insertion. Short with a narrow neck and a flat, rectangular base, it’s nice and inexpensive for someone just starting out. You will have to reapply a water-based lubricant often as it is a silicone toy, but at a low price point and perfect size, it’s a good starter.

Bottom Line

Lovehoney Classic Silicone Extra Petite Beginner's Butt Plug is an economical option if you just want to try a longer term butt plug wear. When you are ready to move up, they have similar larger options in the same line.

2. Jelly Rancher Pleasure Beginner's Butt Plug with Suction Cup



  • Flexible
  • Comes in pretty colors
  • Short length / Narrow neck
  • Can be used with silicone lubricant


  • Base might be too small for some
  • Some users complain that it slides out easily
  • Porous thermoplastic as opposed to silicone (may retain odors)

Another beginner option, the Jelly Rancher Pleasure Beginner's Butt Plug is slightly larger than the Lovehoney Extra Petite and has a smaller, suction cup shaped base.

Another plus on this one is that it is made of thermoplastic (TPE) which means is safe to use with a super slippery silicone lube.

Bottom Line

Pretty and cute, the Jelly Rancher Pleasure Beginner's Butt Plug is another good starter option, especially if you would prefer a silicone lubricant.

3. Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug



  • Flexible
  • Silicone
  • Short length / Narrow neck
  • Comfortable curved base shape


Rounding out our tour of beginner all-day wear butt plugs, we’ve got a third base shape option in Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug.

With a base designed to curve with your body, this might be one of the most comfortable choices if you plan to sit with your plug in.

Bottom Line

Setting aside the bother of having to reapply your water-based lube, Doc Johnson Mood Naughty looks like the most comfortable of our first three beginner butt plug options.

4. Roll Play Small Butt Plug with Jiggle Ball and Suction Cup



  • Flexible
  • Silicone
  • Super fun jiggle ball
  • Short length / Narrow neck


Now, we’re getting creative. Roll Play Small Butt Plug with Jiggle Ball is a small, plump little plug with a round base and surprise steel ball inside.

Every time you move or bend, that little ball jiggles around providing extra surprise stimulation.

Bottom Line

A beginner butt plug with oomph? Yes, please. Roll Play Small Butt Plug with Jiggle Ball is a fan favorite, but you can get it in the slightly larger medium size if you are a more experienced user. 

5. Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug



  • Silicone
  • Somewhat flexible
  • Curved to hit the P-spot
  • Short length / Narrow neck
  • Taint stimulation due to long base


  • Firmer than our other plugs
  • water-based lube will need to be used and reapplied

Something special for the fellas: Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug has a curve to hit his prostate - that magical male equivalent to the G-spot. The base also curved to the body with just enough length to give him extra stimulation on the perineum.

Bottom Line

Like all the other plugs on this list, Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug received tons of rave reviews. With its unique and slightly firmer shape, it is a great option for all day wear if you are a guy and looking for a little more stimulation that other all-day plugs.

Considerations When Buying an All Day Butt Plug

Experience Level

As noted earlier, all-day butt plug wear is not for the novice.

Be sure that you are comfortable with short term wear and start with the smallest option first until you are sure how your body reacts to the material, shape and width of your plug.


Butt Plugs come in various materials from plastic and silicone to glass and metals. For the reasons cited above, we recommend flexible materials like silicone and jelly-like plastics.

Silicone is preferable as it is non-porous, hypoallergenic and soft to the touch, but depending on the kind of lube that works best for you, you may need to go with a plastic like TPE instead. 

Lube and Relube-ing

Cardinal rule of lube and toys: Do not use silicone lube with silicone toys as it can damage them. Cardinal rule of anal play: Silicone lube is best for anal play because it is absorbs slowly and lasts longer. What to do?

In the case of all-day butt plug wear, if you go with a silicone toy, you will need to use a water-based lubricant and reapply often. If you don’t want to carry around lube all day or if you need more lubrication than water-based lubes can provide, you’ll need to consider a non-silicone toy

Safety first when it comes to wearing a butt plug all day.  

Safety Concerns if You Want to Try an All Day Butt Plug

You MUST use Lube 

The backdoor doesn’t roll out the red carpet like the front door. In other words, the rectum does not self-lubricate like a vagina. You will need lube. Lots of lube.

Silicone is best because it will last the longest, but it isn’t compatible with all plugs. If you must use a water-based lubricant with your toy, remember to remove the plug and reapply the lube throughout the day.

Also, consider using a lubricant applicator to get more of the good stuff further in. Read our buyers guide on the best lube for butt plugs if you are interested in learning more.

Work Up To All Day Usage

Don’t plug up and run to work the first day! Try out your plug, wear it around the house to see if it is comfortable and if you can walk, sit, bend over, etc.

Start with shorter wear times first to make sure you don’t have any reaction or minor irritation to the materials or shape. Wearing it around the house first will also give you an idea of how often you will need to reapply lubricant. 

Basic Safe Plug Rules Still Apply

Don’t try to plug with a bullet or other non-anal toy! Butt plugs must have a wide base to prevent it from being sucked inside. Emergency room trips to get a toy out of your rear are embarrassing for everyone involved. 

Take it Out to Poop

Obviously. Re-lubricate before inserting.


With a few precautions and the right smaller, flexible plug (and LUBE!), you may be able to work up to all-day butt plug wear and enjoy this spicy little secret in your life.

Leave a Comment