The Best Anal Sex Toys of 2018 | Complete Buyer’s Guide

The mere mention of anal stimulation can make some people very nervous.

They are afraid it will be painful, but stimulation of the several nerves in the anus can enhance your pleasure.

All you need to go about anal penetration correctly is patience, some good lubricant, and the right toy.

We’ve rated the best anal sex toys for men, women, beginners, and couples for introducing back-door fun into your sex life.

Best Anal Toys | Comparison Chart

To make things easier, feel free to click the links below and fast-travel to the best anal toy per category. 

Types of Anal Toys

Three main types of anal toys:

  • Anal Beads
  • Anal Dildos 
  • Butt Plugs

Each types comes in several different shapes, styles, and designs.

All three models are ideal for either self-pleasure or use with a partner. They make proper introductions to anal stimulation, and you can experiment to see which type of penetration works for you.

Most anal toys have vibrating models, designed to relax the muscles and stimulate the nerve endings in the anus.

Anal Beads

Our Top Pick

Tracey Cox Supersex

Anal Beads with Finger Loop

Starting are small silicone or plastic beads, linked by pieces of thinner string or thicker silicone. The spheres are all one size, or they can graduate from smaller to larger for extra stimulation.

At the end of the beads is a strong base, such as a hook or a handle, to keep your grip on the toy during penetration.

Inserting the beads one at a time and slowly pulling them out arouses the nerve endings in your anus.

Since anal beads are more versatile than other toys, they make perfect items for beginners who want to experiment with anal stimulation.

Anal Dildos

Our Top Pick

Lovehoney Slimline Silicone

Suction Cup Dildo

Also known as anal probes, anal dildos are a fun way to test the feeling of anal sex before trying it.

Some are phallic-shaped, so they make an excellent introduction to anal penetration by a partner.

The shape of anal dildos allow for movement, so you or a partner can slide the toy in and out at a comfortable speed that feels the best to you.

They come in a variety of materials, such as jelly, plastic, silicone, or glass. These toys are for those who are more experienced with anal toys and want to graduate to anal sex.

Butt Plugs

Our Top Pick

BASICS Slimline Butt Plug

Unlike anal beads and anal dildos, butt plugs remain inside of you after insertion.

With a smooth, tapered head that looks like a rounded triangle, the end of the plug has a wider base that rests against your sphincter.

This design allows you to slowly and gradually penetrate the anus, leaving the toy in during foreplay or sex. Plugs come in a variety of materials, such as plastic, silicone, or glass.

They range in size, from small to large. You can start small and work up to whichever size makes you feel the most comfortable. Butt plugs are a great way to stretch your anus before intercourse with your partner.

Quick Take - The Best Anal Toys

Here are our top picks for the best anal toys per category: 

  1. Best Anal Toy Overall: BASICS Slimline Butt Plug
  2. Best Anal Sex Toy for Women: B-Vibe Rimming Petite
  3. Best Anal Sex Toy for Beginners: Tracey Cox Supersex Silicone Anal Beads
  4. Best Anal Sex Toy for Men: Lovehoney Ripple Rider Vibrating Prostate Massager
  5. Best Anal Sex Toy for Couples: Lovehoney Bumper Booty Bundle Toy Kit (6 Piece)

Review of the Best Anal Sex Toys

When experimenting with anal penetration, you need to have the right equipment.

Combined with a quality lubricant, a good toy can make anal play more enjoyable for both you and your partner. 

From plugs to beads and probes, these top-rated anal toys of 2018 are comfortable and suited to any budget.

1. Best Overall Anal Toy: BASICS Slimline Butt Plug

Do you want to dive into anal pleasure, but you aren’t sure where to start?

The BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is so small that it can fit in the palm of your hand. At only 4.5 inches of insertable length, the BASICS has a tapered and rounded tip for easy insertion, designed to resemble the tip of a finger.

The girth from the tip to the end doesn’t vary that much in size, making it much less intimidating for first-timers. Its narrow neck and tapered men keep the plug in place comfortably after insertion.

The soft, waterproof PVC material is firm for penetration, but it flexes to accommodate your body. The BASICS Slimline Butt Plug’s size and comfort make it ideal for those wanting to start experimenting with anal penetration.    

Pros

  • Easy to clean
  • No plastic, rubbery scent
  • Flexible and durable
  • Feels soft and comfortable when inserted
  • Suction cup base attaches to any flat surface

Cons

  • More experienced users say it is too small
  • The plug can feel sticky, especially when the lubricant dries out
  • The PVC material can attract dust; it is best to store it in a bag when not in use

Bottom Line

It’s always best to start simple. The BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is a gently graduated tapered plug that isn’t too long so it won’t be intimidating for you.

Although some who have more experience in anal play believe that it is too thin and small, the BASICS would make a good warm-up toy before moving up to larger sizes.

For those who are unsure of whether or not they will like anal stimulation, the BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is a great way to test the waters.

2. Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit (3 Piece)

Investing in one butt plug sounds like fun; why not three?

The Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit is a set of butt plugs that come in three different sizes: petite, medium, and large. Ideal for both men and women, the Jelly Ranchers have suction cup bottoms that attach to any flat surface.

They are compatible with water-based and silicone-based lubricant, so you won’t be limited in the product you decide to use with them.

The Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit is for those who are looking to slowly increase their anal pleasure to include anal penetration by a partner.

Pros

  • Gender inclusive
  • Tapers increase with size
  • Compatible with all lubricants
  • Helpful for graduating up to anal penetration
  • Suction cup bottoms stick to any flat surface

Cons

  • An inch difference in circumference between the plugs
  • Dramatic size difference between the plugs, especially between medium and large

Bottom Line

Butt plugs are useful tools for anal penetration. The Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit comes in three sizes, so you don’t have to invest in another plug once you get used to the one you have.

You can use either water-based or silicone-based lubricant with this set, a bonus feature over other toys that can only tolerate water-based lube. The size difference in the plugs is very pronounced, so you’ll need to go slow with this set.

3. Lovehoney Slimline Silicone Suction Cup Dildo

If plugs and beads aren’t your thing, then choosing a simple anal dildo is best for enjoying anal penetration.

The Lovehoney Slimline Silicone Suction Cup Dildo 5 inch has a simple design that isn’t overwhelming. It is slightly curved for both anal and vaginal penetration, reaching the g-spot in women and the prostate in men.

The dildo is firm and flexible, designed to slide into the anus comfortably. Its ergonomic shape makes movement easy.

The flared base is compatible with harnesses with a 1.25” ring, and the toy is waterproof for cleaning and tub and shower fun. Compatible with water-based lubricant, the Lovehoney Slimline Silicone Suction Cup Dildo is another option for beginners to anal sex.

Pros

  • For vaginal or anal play
  • Waterproof; easy to clean
  • Great for beginners
  • No plastic, rubbery odor
  • Flared suction cup at the base
  • Firm and flexible enough for insertion
  • Compatible with water-based lubricant
  • Compatible with ring harnesses (1.25” ring)
  • Simple, smooth design easy to rotate and move during penetration
  • 5” anal dildo curved to fit your anatomy (G-spot and P-spot)

Cons

  • Small suction cup
  • Too flexible for harness
  • Imprinted logo on shaft dildo hard to clean
  • Too short and thin for experienced

Bottom Line

The Lovehoney Slimline Silicone Suction Cup Dildo is the ideal choice for a first anal dildo. It’s simple, streamlined design works for either vaginal or anal penetration, and it is compatible with ring harnesses that take 1.25” rings.

This waterproof dildo has a gentle curve and a smooth feel: combined with a water-based lubricant, it moves well for use with a partner or going solo.

There is an imprinted logo on the shaft that can be a little more difficult to clean, but this isn’t a major design flaw. Experienced users claim the dildo is too short and thin, so this is purely a beginner’s item.

4. Rocks Off Bubbles Sensations Plug

If you have used a butt plug before, you may want to experience different textures. The Rocks Off Bubbles Sensations Plug is a mixture of a butt plug and anal beads.

The toy is handheld and easy to maneuver while your anus stretches to it. With graduated bumps that range from ¼” to 1”, this waterproof butt plug has a flared base with a 7-function vibrator that takes an N battery that is included with the toy.

The strong vibrations will stimulate the nerve endings in your anus and relax your muscles, making penetration even more pleasurable.

The Rocks Off has a smooth silicone exterior, and it is hypoallergenic, ideal for those who have sensitivities or allergies to toys.

Suitable for use during solo play or with your partner, it is perfect for those who have experienced both anal beads and a butt plug. The Rocks Off Bubbles offers the best of both worlds.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Hypoallergenic
  • N battery included
  • Smooth silicone exterior
  • Strong, 7 function vibrator
  • Graduated bumps (1/4” to 1”)
  • Perfect for solo or partner use
  • Flared base has a hole for the insertable bullet

Cons

  • The tip is too flexible
  • 3” insertion; for beginners only
  • Hard to turn off push-button vibrator before removal when you are alone

Bottom Line

The Rocks Off Bubbles Sensations Plug is a plug with a bulbed exterior that can help you experience different thicknesses during anal penetration.

At only 3”, it is designed for beginners only; those who have used longer plugs will be disappointed.

The vibration is optional, so you can experience how it feels with or without it. This plug is better to use with a partner since it can be tricky to turn off the vibration before you remove it.

If you like the sensation of anal beads, but you don’t like the large spaces between them, then the Rocks Off Bubbles would be a good investment.

5. Lovehoney Butt Tingler Vibrating Butt Plug

Small butt plugs are the go-to toy for some beginners to anal penetration. They aren’t as textured as anal beads, and they are smaller than most anal dildos.

The Lovehoney Butt Tingler 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug is a small vibrating butt plug for those who enjoy simplicity in their toys.

The taper is slightly rounded for more comfortable penetration, and it has a T-shaped anchor that houses a wireless vibrator. The bullet is easily removable, and the entire toy is waterproof.

This makes the Butt Tingler easier to clean, and you can bring it in the shower for even more fun. This latex-free silicone butt plug takes a AAA battery, resulting in strong vibrations in all the right places.

Pros

  • Latex-free; made with a soft and durable silicone
  • Waterproof for easy cleaning and shower fun
  • Strong, removable bullet with 2 speeds, 3 patterns takes a AAA battery
  • T-shaped anchor to hold it in place
  • A slightly rounded taper for easy insertion
  • Simple vibrating butt plug for beginners

Cons

  • Too small for experienced users
  • Vibrations are loud; sensitive on-off button
  • Bullet sticks out of the long handle; not meant for sitting

Bottom Line

Vibrating butt plugs can provide extra stimulation and relaxation during anal play. With only 3.5” of insertable length, the Lovehoney Butt Tingler 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug is designed for those new to the scene of anal play.

Although the vibrations are loud, the strong bullet excites the sensitive nerve endings in your anus. The simple design and intense stimulation make it worth trying out.  

6. LuxGem Beginner’s Metal Butt Plug with Pink Jewel

Metal toys are less common than silicone or latex toys, but they are much safer for your body. They are completely non-porous, so they are much easier to clean.

The smooth exterior of metal also glides better than other materials when properly lubricated. Many women like the LuxGem Beginner’s Metal Butt Plug with Pink Jewel 2.5 inch because it is aesthetically pleasing.

It is short and tapered, with a 3.7” circumference at the widest point. There is also a pink jewel on the bottom of the base that sparkles in the light.

The non-porous aluminum is one of the easiest materials to clean. The metal gives some weight to the plug, and it holds temperature well.

Running the LuxGem Beginner’s Metal Butt Plug over warm or cold water allows for temperature play in the bedroom.

Pros

  • pro 1
  • Easy to clean
  • Small size good for beginners
  • Short and tapered
  • Holds temperature; can warm or cool it by running it under water

Cons

  • Some weight to it
  • The jeweled base isn’t flat
  • Not a small taper; resembles a bulb

Bottom Line

The idea of metal toys may cause some shoppers to hesitate, but they are some of the most sanitary anal toys you can use.

Unlike other beginner plugs with a slightly graduated taper, the size of LuxGem Beginner’s Metal Butt Plug with Pink Jewel 2.5 inch resembles a bulb more than a plug.

The rounded shape isn’t that thick, so it is preferable to beginners. Keep in mind that the base isn’t flat, and the textured jewel on the bottom will make sitting on the toy difficult.

However, the option to test different temperatures make this plug a must-own item for those who think outside the box in the pursuit of pleasure.

7. Best Anal Sex Toy for Women: B-Vibe Rimming Petite

A more sophisticated example of a butt plug, the B-Vibe Rimming Petite combines the feeling of an insertable plug with the sensation of rimming (stimulation of the anus with the tongue.)

As beads in the base rotate to stimulate your opening, the B-vibe vibrates inside of you. With strong but quiet vibrations, the plug has 7 functions and 6 speeds so that you can find the right combination for you.

It works for solo play, but more adventurous couples will love the remote-control vibrations that operate within a distance of thirty feet.

The silicone B-vibe is hypoallergenic, so those with severe allergies to latex (or have mild irritations with other sex toys) will find it comfortable and smooth upon insertion.

The B-vibe Rimming Petite offers enough variety and stimulation to make it our choice for the best anal sex toy for women.    

Pros

  • Only takes two hours to charge
  • Remote control has a 30-ft range
  • Compatible with water-based anal lube
  • Comes with a USB charger and a storage case
  • Vibrating butt plug designed to simulate rimming
  • 3.9 inches of insertable length great for beginners
  • 7 function, 6-speed vibrations travel throughout the toy
  • Vibrations and functions ideal for those who want to upgrade their anal play
  • Push button or remote control option for changing speeds/functions or turning on/off
  • Long neck and extended flared base give you more control over insertion and removal

Cons

  • Not waterproof
  • Uses CR2032 battery
  • Controls to switch back and forth take some getting used to
  • Only an hour of use on a full charge

Bottom Line

The B-vibe Rimming Petite is a body-safe option for women looking to take their anal play to the next level.

With battery-operated or remote-control options, the plug is fun for both solo and couples play. The long neck and flared base make insertion and removal more comfortable than other toys, and it comes with its own charger and case for discreet storage.

There have been a few minor complaints about the design of the toy, such as the length the charge and the feel of the rimming mechanism.

However, its benefits outweigh the negatives, making the B-vibe our choice for the best anal sex toy for women.

8. Best Anal Sex Toy for Beginners: Tracey Cox Supersex Silicone Anal Beads with Finger Loop

Investing in a good pair of anal beads can give you a good idea of whether or not you want to explore more anal stimulation.

This smooth and flexible toy has ten beads that gradually increase in size, from 1.2 to 3 inches of circumference. The spacing between the beads is about the width of a finger so you can insert the toy as fast or as slow as you like.

The Tracey Cox Supersex Anal Beads are latex-free silicone, which is very easy to clean after use. The double finger loop makes insertion and removal convenient, whether you are alone or with a partner.

The Tracey Cox Supersex Silicone Anal Beads with Finger Loop 12 inch are a comfortable and durable introduction to the world of anal penetration, making it our choice as the best anal sex toy for beginners.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Flexible silicone
  • More hygienic than string anal beads
  • Double finger loop for insertion and removal
  • Smooth feeling silicone is latex-free and easy to clean
  • 10 beads in graduated size with ample space between them for experimentation

Cons

  • 12” length of the toy can intimidate first-time anal bead users
  • All of the beads are small; not much of a size difference from the smallest to the largest
  • First beads take some patience to insert: they are very flexible and slippery when lubricated

Bottom Line

Anal beads are best for beginners, but some newbies hesitate to try them.

The Tracey Cox Supersex Silicone Anal Beads with Finger Loop have small spheres that are well-spaced and slightly graduated for easy insertion.

Double finger loops easily fit on the hand; using them to pull the beads out slowly during your orgasm will heighten the sensation.

The hooks are large enough that you can experiment with vibrations by placing a bullet in one of the finger holes. Those more experienced don’t like that all of the beads are small, so these are better for first-timers.

9. Best Anal Sex Toy for Men: Lovehoney Ripple Rider 5 Function Vibrating Prostate Massager

You’ve heard of a woman’s G-spot, but did you know that men have one, too?

The prostate is one of the most erogenous zones for men, capable of bringing your orgasm to a higher level. Prostate massagers have a curved design to stimulate a man’s prostate during sex or solo sessions.

The Lovehoney Ripple Rider 5 Function Vibrating Prostate Massager is a flexible and soft 5” wave-shaped plug with a curved tip and a T-shaped anchor that rests against the prostate and the perineum.

The 5 function, push-button vibrator stimulates all of your sensitive areas, bringing on more intense orgasms than sex or masturbation alone.

This hands-free toy is flexible and easy to clean, and it conveniently takes one AAA battery. The Lovehoney Ripple Rider 5 Function is our choice for the best anal sex toy for men.  

Pros

  • Takes 1 AAA battery
  • 5” vibrating massager with a curved tip that stimulates the prostate
  • Hands-free toy for prostate stimulation during sex or masturbation
  • 5-functions of vibration travel throughout the whole toy
  • Push-button bullet for changing functions or turning on/off
  • T-shaped flared anchor base stimulates the perineum
  • Wave shape slides in easily and fits your anatomy
  • Waterproof for water play and cleaning
  • Latex-free; flexible silicone is soft to the touch and easy to clean

Cons

  • Smooth material collects dust; keep in a storage bag
  • Bullet takes some effort to remove during cleaning
  • For intermediate users; thickness intimidating to those new to anal penetration

Bottom Line

The Lovehoney Ripple Rider 5 Function Vibrating Prostate Massager reaches the sensitive parts of the male anatomy, intensifying orgasms and bringing pleasure to the experience of anal penetration.

There are a few design flaws with the toy: the vibrations are very loud, and the bullet can be hard to remove when you are cleaning it.

The vibrator sticks out from the base, so you can’t sit on it like other plugs. The girth can intimidate some beginners, so it is best for those with experience.

However, the shape and stimulation that the toy provides make it our selection as the best anal sex toy for men.     

10. Best Anal Sex Toy for Couples: Lovehoney Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Toy Kit (6 Piece)

Choosing the right anal toy can be overwhelming because there are so many options. The Lovehoney Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Toy Kit suits anyone who wants an introduction to the varied models of anal penetration toys.

The set comes with two plugs, one set of anal beads, a prostate massager, and an anal douche. All of the toys are latex-free, made of body-safe silicone that is easy to clean.

A 10-function removable bullet that takes a AAA battery is included so that you can experiment with vibrations with your toys.

Everything in the set is compatible with a water-based anal lubricant to make them more pleasurable. The Lovehoney Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Toy Kit includes items for both men and women, making it a top choice for couples.     

Pros

  • Ideal for beginner solo or partner play
  • Kit of a variety of anal toy materials (2 butt plugs with flared bases, anal beads, prostate massage, anal douche, and bullet vibe)
  • Latex-free silicone is soft and smooth to the touch; easy to clean
  • All toys (except the douche) have the option for vibration; bullet included
  • Quiet, 10 multifunction bullet takes AAA battery
  • Plugs have tapered tips and flared bases
  • Anal beads and prostate massager have a T-shaped handle
  • Compatible with water-based anal lubricant

Cons

  • Takes some effort to remove the bullet from the toys
  • Plugs are similar in size
  • Length of anal beads can intimidate first-timers
  • Vibrations aren’t as strong as other toys; don’t reach the top of some of the toys

Bottom Line

The Lovehoney Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Toy Kit (6 piece) comes with every toy style available for both men and women. It is an ideal purchase for couples who want to try everything.

The versatility of the toys, including the vibrating option, makes it our choice for the best anal toy for couples. Although the bullet is included, some have complained that it isn’t strong enough.

The anal beads are rather large, and they can intimidate the receiver for first-time anal play. This set is best for couples who have tried anal penetration before, and they want to pursue it further.

How to Use Anal Toys

There are three essential steps to using anal toys: relaxation, lubrication, and a warm-up.

Relaxation

The muscles of your anus tighten when you are stressed or nervous. You can loosen your muscles by taking a long, hot bath or shower, or doing anything that relaxes you before your session.

Lubrication

Most toys are only compatible with water-based lubricants.

Water-based anal lubricants are thicker and last longer than other water-based selections.

Always apply a more than generous amount to yourself and your toy before starting.

The anus doesn’t self-lubricate like the vagina, so you should never try anal play without lubrication.

Warm-up

You should always start slow when beginning anal penetration. Stimulate your opening with a lubed finger or the small tip of a toy.

As your body starts to relax, slowly edge in the toy or edge your body against it. Anal penetration is a unique sensation that takes some time to get used to feeling.

Insert the toy a few centimeters at a time, using a rotating motion until you can feel the toy comfortably inside of you.

During orgasm, all of the muscles in your body tense up. After your session is over, relax for a few minutes in your afterglow before slowly removing your toy. Adding some extra lubricant can help the toy slide out easier.

How to Clean Anal Toys

While antibacterial soap and water work for most toys, you should invest in an antibacterial toy cleaner for your anal toys.

This cleaner comes in wipe, spray, or liquid form.

Apply a generous amount, letting it sit for a few minutes before wiping your toy down with a warm cloth.

Dry with a soft rag and store in a container or another cool, dry place.

Conclusion

Anal toys are great tools for experimenting with anal penetration, but the most important part of this experience is trusting yourself and your partner.

When selecting a toy for masturbation, you are the boss: choose one that looks comfortable to you. If you will be using the toy with a partner, then communication is a must.

Talking out your plans and fantasies will help you take this journey together.

Leave a Comment