2019 Complete Buyer’s Guide: The Best Butt Plugs

If you want to enter the world of anal play, a butt plug is a great place to start. There are thousands of butt plugs available that can help you achieve intense orgasms during both solo and partner play.  

In this review, we’ll give you the rundown on what butt plugs are, how they, work and the best ones out there. Let’s get started.

Comparison Chart of the Best Butt Plugs

What is a Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a sex toy designed to be inserted into your ass for pleasure. Butt plugs come in a variety of shapes, colors, and textures. Some are even inflatable if your ultimate goal is stretching. Generally, butt plugs are pear or bullet-shaped objects which have larger, rounded bases. This type of sex toy intensifies stimulation when inserted in your ass.

Butt plugs are designed to stay in place during active play or when walking around, making for either simulating double penetration or a fun little secret as you go through the day. Butt plugs help you enjoy a deeper climax by allowing for hands-free action while you stimulate other erogenous zones. A butt plug can be used with a partner or while masturbating to help bring you to a more satisfying orgasm.

What Makes a Great Butt Plug?

Below are the features of a quality model:

Size

Whether you are just beginning or use butt plugs on a regular basis, there is a butt plug for you. Beginners are better suited buying a butt plug that is 0.75” in width, or the equivalent of inserting one finger. Advanced users may want something wider, around 1.5” or more. The length varies on a butt plug from 1” to 8” and sometimes even longer. Remember, the average finger is 3” long and the average male penis is 6” in length.

Texture

The texture of the butt plug can vary too. Butt plugs can be smooth, nubbed, ribbed, or a combination of all of the above. Butt plugs are tapered to stay in place once inserted Typically, a variety of textures are combined to help make a climax more memorable.

Material

Material is important when it comes to choosing the right butt plug. Butt plugs can involve a lot of bacteria which can harmful to other, sensitive parts of your body. Silicone, stainless steel, and glass are the safest materials for your body. These materials can easily be cleaned with a good toy cleaner. Jelly materials, on the other hand, are porous and can contain bacteria even after cleaning.

Types of Butt Plugs

There are numerous types of butt plugs that each offer their own unique style of stimulation. Most butt plugs are tapered so they can stay in your ass without you holding the object in place. Butt plugs generally have a ring-pull, flared base, or a handle to help with insertion and removal.

When you are looking to purchase a butt plug you will notice many types, such as those that are vibrating or studded with a jewel for aesthetics. Butt plugs can be pieces of artwork made of glass. There are also fetish butt plugs that look like a cat or dog’s tail. A stand-alone category is an inflatable butt plug which allows you to pump air into the shaft to increase pressure to your desire.

Review of the Best Butt Plugs

Now that you know the basics of a butt plug, let’s take a look at some of the best models on the market. During our review process, we’ll highlight main features then provide some positive and negative feedback on each model.

1. Jet Anal Trainer Kit Carbon Metallic Black 3 Butt Plugs

Pros

  • Tapered shaft
  • Latex free PVC 
  • Narrow base for long term wear
  • Set of three butt plugs
  • Graduating sizes are perfect for all users

Cons

  • Not silicone

The Jet Anal Trainer Kit Carbon Metallic Black 3 Butt Plugs is found to be an excellent training kit for all experience levels and features three distinct sizes.

The first butt plug is ideal for beginners and has a 3.5” insertable smooth, tapered shaft with a 1.25” widest point. The second size is slightly larger at 4.75” with a width of 1.5”. The third butt plug is for advanced users and measures 6”, with a width of 1.75”.

The smooth silicone shafts are tapered and supported by a wide but narrow base that is comfortable for long term wear. These work best when used with your favorite water-based lubricant.

Bottom Line

The Jet Anal Trainer Kit Carbon Metallic Black 3 Butt Plugs is a great addition to anyone’s sex toy box. The three graduating sizes help stretch users out while also providing enough pressure for pleasure. The PVC material holds up well after several uses and the long, narrow base makes for long wearing fun.


2. Bum Bum Beginner Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Flared base 
  • Silicone material
  • Great for beginner to intermediate users
  • Tapered tip makes for easy insertion

Cons

  • Weak vibrations for some users
  • Difficult to control vibrations once it's inserted

The Bum Bum Beginner Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug is loved by many due its waterproof construction and vibrating mechanics. The bulbous shaft is 3” in insertable length with a width of 1.57” and its widest point, and is designed with an ultra smooth texture and pointed tip which makes for easy insertion.

The silicone material is a bonus, making it easy to clean and disinfect but some users found the bullet controls hard to manage once the toy was inserted. 

Bottom Line

The Bum Bum Beginner Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug is a well-rounded pick, however some report that they wish the vibrations were stronger at times. The overall size is perfect for most users, especially beginners. If you’re looking for a butt plug that’s versatile, this is a great option.


3. Temptasia Bling Plugs Training Kit with Rainbow Gem Ends

Pros

  • Heart shaped base with cute gem
  • Silicone material 
  • Perfect sizes for beginners and intermediate users

Cons

  • Not as comfortable for long term wear

The Temptasia Bling Plugs Training Kit with Rainbow Gem Ends is well received by beginners who are looking for a gradual advancement during anal play. The kit contains three distinctly sized butt plugs: a smaller model that measures 2.6” long insertable and 1” at its widest, the middle is 2.8" by 1.4" and a larger plug that offers a 3.2” insertable shaft and is 1.75” wide.

The tapered tip makes these easy to insert with some water based lubricant and the narrow neck helps to anchor them in place. Although the base is not ideal for long term wear or sitting with them inserted, users still found them a fun and easy to use plug set. 

Bottom Line

The Temptasia Bling Plugs Training Kit with Rainbow Gem Ends is ideal for beginners and intermediate users. The gem base adds an element of fun to a classic plug design and the sizes are perfect for those who want to work their way up to taking something larger. 


4. Quickie Kit Anal Play Vibrating Plug & Anal Beads

Pros

  • Made from Body Safe Materials. Contains No Fragrances, Phthalates, Paraffins, or Latex
  • Multi-speed vibrator 
  • Two distinctly different anal play  styles
  • Perfect for beginners or intermediate usersR
  • Remote control 

Cons

  • PVC material
  • Weak vibrations
  • Remote wire gets in the way

The Quickie Kit Anal Play Vibrating Plug & Anal Beads is a winner for those who are looking for a versatile anal kit that provides two styles of toys. The classic butt plug shape is 3.25” in insertable length and 1.25” at its widest, and features a wired remote with a simple dial control for vibrations. 

The second toy is a long, slender anal bead set at 12.75" in length (10.25" Insertable) and 1" width. The intensely tapered tip makes for easy insertion and the looped handle not only stops the toy from going in far but allows you to pull it in and out for amazing sensations. 

Bottom Line

The Quickie Kit Anal Play Vibrating Plug & Anal Beads is ideal for all experience levels. The vibration patterns are adequate for most users and help with stronger, more fulfilling orgasms and the anal beads are well made and fun to experiment with for different sensations. 


5. Firefly Ace 2 Glow in the Dark Silicone Butt Plug

Pros

  • Flexible
  • Flared handle for easy use
  • Two raised bubble style ribs
  • Great size for beginners and intermediate users
  • Silicone and glow in the dark

Cons

  • May be too long for absolute beginners

The Firefly Ace 2 Glow in the Dark Silicone Butt Plug provides lots of simple anal fun to users who are seeking a unique, ribbed toy. The 4” insertable shaft has ribs fashioned after bubbles to add more stimulation upon insertion.

The width of the shaft is tapered and measures 1.25”, which is sufficient for pleasurable pressure during varying speeds. Additionally, the base features a flared handle which is ideal for holding onto, even when your hands are slippery with lube.

The flexibility of this material makes this plug great for long term wear, helped by the long, narrow base. Some users found this slightly long for absolute beginners. 

Bottom Line

The Firefly Ace 2 Glow in the Dark Silicone Butt Plug is a great addition to someone looking for a gift or a new toy for their personal collection. The size is ideal for nearly all experience levels and the shaft has enhanced ribs for added stimulation. Moreover, the flared handle is perfect for grip, even with lots of lubrication. A must have for those who love some anal play every now and then.


6. Booty Sparks Red Rose Anal Plug

Pros

  • Great for temperature play
  • Elegant design
  • Nice size for all users
  • Red rose base 

Cons

  • Advanced users wanted more length and girth
  • Not comfortable for long term wear or sitting
  • Too rigid for some users
  • Not stainless steel

The Booty Sparks Red Rose Anal Plug proves to be a favorite for buyers looking for an upscale look or a romantic gift. The small butt plug has a smooth finish with a tapered shaft that measures 2” insertable length and features a width of 1.25”.

The base features a red rose that’s pretty and elegant when inserted. The aluminum allow material is great for temperature variations, which can add even more stimulation into the mix. This rose plug is a top pick for those searching for some anal jewelry.

Bottom Line

The Booty Sparks Red Rose Anal Plug is a must have when you or your partner wants to look more elegant during anal play. The beautiful shape and rose design showcased between the cheeks is a real turn-on for most users. 


7. Spark Silicone Carbon Fiber Butt Plug - Large 

Pros

  • Circular base
  •  Advanced length and girth
  • Classic design and style
  • Body safe, non-porous silicone material

Cons

  • Too large for many users

The Spark Silicone Carbon Fiber Butt Plug is a big hit with more advanced users who are looking for size and girth. The smooth tapered shaft has an insertable length of 5.75”, while the width of 2.5” does an excellent job of providing that ‘full’ feeling. The circular handle is easy to grasp too while using a good lubricant.

Bottom Line

The Spark Silicone Carbon Fiber Butt Plug has a simplistic style and design, which is ideal for advanced users who are looking for a durable butt plug. The product holds up well during rapid movements and the silicone material is body safe and non-porous. There’s nothing fancy with this butt plug, but simplicity makes for a great option.


8. Petite Sensations Bubbles Butt Plug

Pros

  • Futuristic look
  • Good for all sexes
  • Great length and width
  • Flexible for P-spot stimulation

Cons

  • Circular base
  • No suction cup
  • Sil-A-Gel can absorb bacteria if not cleaned properly

The Petite Sensations Bubbles Butt Plug is a superb choice for users looking for a non-traditional design in an anal toy. The 4” insertable shaft features numerous raised ribs that are complemented with a 1.25” width.

The base contains a powerful bullet vibrator that adds amazing sensations to your play.  For the cleanest results, be sure to wash the butt plug with a good toy cleaner.

Bottom Line

The Petite Sensations Bubbles Butt Plug brings a sleek look and design to a simple, yet satisfying butt plug. With this, the ribbed shaft is flexible enough to add a new dimension to P-spot climaxes. The bullet adds a great new dimension of fun. 


9. Naughty Candy Heart Butt Plug

Pros

  • Classic design
  • Silicone material
  • Extra girth and length for advanced users
  • Fun heart-shaped handle available with three messages

Cons

  • Not great for beginners

The Naughty Candy Heart Butt Plug shows users a little more love with its classic design and heart shaped handle. The 3” smooth shaft is tapered for easy insertion and features a width of 1.5”.

The butt plug has a heart-shaped handle and can be purchased with three different messages engraved of the heart: Spank Me, Do Me Now, and Be Mine. The silicone material is flexible yet firm and works well with water-based lubricants.

Bottom Line

The Naughty Candy Heart Butt Plug receives high marks from users who enjoy extra length and girth from a butt plug. The heart-shaped handle is a real winner with several different messages available to buyers. Users really love this butt plug for everyday wear while working or relaxing at home. This pretty plug is a great addition to anyone’s pleasure chest.


10. Pom Plugs - Fur Pom Pom Butt Plugs

Pros

  • Fun and sexy for role play
  • Good beginner size and shape
  • Base designed for long term wear
  • Body safe silicone and faux fur

Cons

  • Plug may be too small for experienced users
  • Realistic jelly material can be hard to clean

The Pom Plugs - Fur Pom Pom Butt Plugs is an ideal choice for buyers looking for a penis design with realistic features. The slightly curved shaft has a realistic look with numerous lifelike veins and an insertable length of 4.5”.

The head is 1.5” wide, which is perfect for bringing users to an intense climax. The slightly curved shaft adds extra pleasure to the P-spot too. Additionally, the T-shaped handle is easy to manage, even when lube is applied.

Bottom Line

The Pom Plugs - Fur Pom Pom Butt Plugs is a perfect option for more advanced users who want a realistic look and feel to their butt plug. The lifelike feel and appearance provides intense climaxes thanks to its raised veins. The head is easy to insert and the curved shaft helps provide intense P-spot orgasms. Overall, this is a good butt plug and a must have for experienced users.


Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Good for all levels of users
  • T-bar hugs your body and makes removal easy
  • Curved shaft hits all the right places for enhanced orgasms
  • Stays in place, even during rapid movement or while out and about
  • Firm and smooth, making it easy for insertion without any discomfort

Cons

  • No suction cup for hands-free play
  • Could be bigger for more advanced users

First on our list is the Fun Factory Bootie Small Silicone Anal Plug. This butt plug is easy to use, ergonomically designed, and shaped perfectly for mind-blowing prostate massages.

This butt plug for men has a smooth, silicone shaft with a curve for intense P-spot stimulation. It has an insertable length of 4” and circumference of 2.75”. The clever T-bar base helps the butt plug stay in place while also providing external stimulation.

The Fun Factory Bootie Small Silicone Anal Plug is recommended for all users, from those just starting out to those with tons of experience. With the right water-based lube, get ready for an amazing orgasmic experience with this butt plug.

Bottom Line

The Fun Factory Bootie Small Silicone Anal Plug is perfect for everyone, from beginners to pros.  The T-bar base helps the butt plug stay in place for intense P-spot stimulation during partner or solo play, or even throughout the day at work or watching TV.

The body-safe silicone is super smooth and comfortable. For extra pleasure, we also recommend a generous dollop of your favorite water-based lube.

In the end, this is the perfect men’s butt plug to have in your toy chest.


12. Alpha Pro 7X P-STROKE Silicone Prostate Stimulator with Stroking Shaft

Pros

  • Silky and smooth to the touch
  • Explosive vibrations (but still quiet!)
  • Tons of variations in vibration mode
  • Discreet storage case for recharging
  • Butt plug is completely waterproof - just not the remote

Cons

  • A little pricier than others
  • Could hold a charge longer

Next, let’s take a look at the Alpha Pro 7X P-STROKE Silicone Prostate Stimulator with Stroking Shaft. This butt plug means business and is the perfect selection for people looking for tons of variety and power behind their P-spot stimulation.

The velvety soft silicone shaft has an insertable length of 3.75”, and a circumference of 4” for a pleasant full feeling. The toy has an L-shaped arm that wraps around your body to send toe-curling vibrations to your perineum while keeping the device in place for easy hands-free play.

One of the best features of this butt plug is its wireless remote control, which is rechargeable via USB in its discreet charging case for a full hour of fun. With the remote you can experiment with 8 vibration modes and 12 speeds for a fully customizable experience. To top it all off, the remote has an 8 meter range so you can even hand it over to your partner for some orgasmic surprises.  

The prostate massager itself is fully submersible for aquatic play. Just remember, the remote control is only splash proof so be careful not to take that with you into the tub.

Bottom Line

The Alpha Pro 7X P-STROKE Silicone Prostate Stimulator with Stroking Shaft is truly the top of the line when it comes to P-spot pleasure. Our pick for best overall buttplug for men, this toy has just about everything you could want.

With tons of options with vibration speed and pattern, an easy-to-use wireless remote control, and L-shape for internal and external stimulation, you may never want to take this massager off.

The only major downside is the price, but you definitely get the bang for your buck. This men’s butt plug is a must try for all levels of users looking to experience the powerful sensation of P-spot climaxes.


13. BASICS Slimline Butt Plug

Pros

  • Small size: As a beginner, small sized butt plugs are all that you need. 4.5’’ will do the job just fine.
  • Compatible with water-based lubricants: This is a great advantage as it will not damage the toy.
  • No latex or phthalates: This is a great advantage of butt plugs at it may decrease the chance of some allergic unwanted reactions to latex.
  • No latex or phthalates: This is a great advantage of butt plugs at it may decrease the chance of some allergic unwanted reactions to latex.

Cons

  • None thus far

This amazing, enchanting toy is for masturbation, foreplay, and sex - and might be everything needed to make your world go around. The size is perfect for beginners, so you shouldn’t have any unwanted pain or inconveniences. It’s 4.5’’ and features a tapered tip for easy insertion.

Furthermore, it has a flared base and narrow neck. This drastically improves the comfort and prolongs any harm of extended use. As you can see, it has a unique shape; hence, it’s a great stimulator that’s sure to cause toe curling orgasms. For the best possible experience, use plenty of lube. It will go in smoothly and decrease any unwanted pain.

Bottom Line

All in all, we conclude that this product offers great value. It features an affordable price point, and the quality received is supreme. Definitely our top pick for the best beginner butt plug.


14. Cupid's Itty Bitty Beginner's Plug

Pros

  • Great size: This butt plug has the perfect size for beginners at 3.75’’. It’s neither too small nor too big.
  • User friendly: The ease of use behind this butt plug will simply amaze you. It has a tapered tip and a finger-pull which will drastically ease your experience.
  • Great materials and lube-friendly: There are no latex or phthalates materials used. Cupid’s Itty Bitty is lube-friendly, so make sure to have some extra slippery fun.

Cons

  • Sticky silicone material feeling: Sometimes, you just can’t ignore its sticky feeling. Some may find it annoying, while others don’t.

This smaller butt plug is made of silicone mostly and a top option for novice users. Cupid’s Itty Bitty is a round butt plug with a bulb center for even more pleasure. It's sure to provide stimulating massages and crazy orgasms.

The silicone is flexible, yet firm, and offers a well-rounded mix of comfort. On the bottom of the plug is a finger-pull, which is for safety. It prevents the butt plug from accidently going too far inside users. With this, you can easily pull it out with ease. It has a slim 0.5” neck and a 1.25’’ flared base. It is extremely easy to use and clean afterward too.

Bottom Line

Taking into consideration all of the aforementioned, there’s no doubt Cupid’s Itty Bitty is our runner-up for the best beginner butt plug. It’s a rounder model that will offer a nice, full feeling. Moreover, it is extremely safe to use and not that expensive as well.


What Do Butt Plugs Do For Women?

Rather than the in and out motion if dildos and internal vibrators, a butt plug for women is a plug and play kind of toy. Once it's in, you don’t need to do anything else with it. It is all about the sensation of the toy inside the booty and the orgasmic opportunities that it offers.

Butt plugs are all about pressure. While women may not have a prostate to massage, they are specifically designed to create a feeling of fullness inside the body, and this feels incredible for women too.

Whether you are masturbating, receiving oral or even being penetrated vaginally, having a butt plug in will make the whole experience much more intense; plus, it can also intensify your orgasm as the sphincter muscles contract around the neck of the plug and hit all those nerve endings that are so often missed.

The use of a butt plug can also indirectly target the female G-spot! Yup, that wall between the colon and the vaginal shaft s actually very thin and a butt plug can work to apply pressure to the g-spot too. It will be even more intense if you use a toy or a penis vaginally too.  

Of course, a butt plug is also a great way to prepare and relax the body before anal sex too. It works by opening and relaxing the sphincter muscles so that a penis can then be inserted instead.

What Do Butt Plugs Do For Men?

For people with male anatomy, the prostate, or P-spot, is a super sensitive region capable of inducing an unforgettable climax. With the help of a butt plug, the P-spot will receive extra stimulation during solo or partner play. During climax, your muscles naturally clench around the butt plug. This clenching gives you a more satisfying sensation of fullness and pleasure.

The design of a butt plug is crucial. Butt plugs with a flared base stay in place easier. They can be used at home or when you’re out and about. Many men will insert a butt plug before work or exercising to increase stimulation and pleasure. Using a good lubricant can increase fun too, by allowing more time for foreplay while getting ready for a fantastic anal climax.

Butt Plugs and Prostate Fun - How it Works!

Butt plugs are easy to use. Their design is user friendly and they should have a flared base or handle for easy removal. The handle or base also makes sure the butt plug does not get inserted too far.

A good P-spot butt plug can be straight and flexible or slightly curved. Once you insert a butt plug and find your P-spot, you can gently massage the area. Massaging the P-spot and the added sensation of fullness a butt plug provides are surefire ways to an extraordinary orgasm.

The material of a good butt plug is crucial. Butt plugs made from silicone are the safest for your body because they are easy to clean. Due to its non-porous characteristics, silicone is the least likely material to carry any type of bacteria after cleaning.

Size is important too. Beginners need to find something comfortable. Typically, the smaller the length and girth makes for a more pleasurable experience right out the gate. Advanced users may seek a stretching sensation with a slightly larger butt plug.

A good butt plug is great for a variety of activities, including solo masturbation, partner play, P-spot stimulation and foreplay. In order to accommodate all of these activities, a butt plug should stay in place but should also have the option for rapid insertion for extra stimulation.

How to Use a Butt Plug

Using a butt plug is easy. All you need to do is insert the butt plug into your rectum and enjoy. On the other hand, ass dildos are designed to stretch your anus and apply pressure to your rectum, intensifying your orgasm.

There are a variety of ways to use a butt plug such as during sex or while performing oral on your partner. Butt plugs can be worn at any time throughout the day, whether you’re awake or sleeping. Keep in mind that prolonged use does increase your chances for bodily harm if you’re not accustomed to the act.  

Using a good lubrication during the process is a must. Stretching your rectum can cause pain and lube will definitely make the insertion process more enjoyable. With this, make sure your lubricant is compatible with the product’s material before applying.

Conclusion

Whether you’re a beginner or a more advanced user, one of these butt plugs is meant for you. The shape and size of these butt plugs are unique and feature qualities from deep ribs to heart-shaped handles and even vibrating extras.

We hope this review has been helpful in your search for a great butt plug and wish you the best in your decision making process. If you end up choosing a model from our list, be sure to put it to the test and let us know how you enjoyed it. We love hearing from guests and look forward to hearing from you! 

Leave a Comment