The Best Soft Dildos of 2019 | Rated and Reviewed Buyer’s Guide

Not only can soft dildos be used for a variety of sexual pleasures, they are predominantly used for wearing and packing. This allows for the wearer to look like they have a penis and/or bulge.

For these reasons, soft dildos such as these are very popular for role-playing and transgender people. 

This article discusses varying types of dildos and the advantages and disadvantages to each. 

Dildos are made of different materials which should be highly considered when making the decision of which product to buy. Soft dildos in particular are a popular choice for buyers due to their realistic look and feel.

Comparison Chart of the Best Soft Dildos

Soft Dildos vs. Hard Dildos

Soft dildos are preferred by those who want a soft, flexible, and realistic feel.

Most soft dildos are made of porous material so knowing exactly what type of material it is composed of is extremely important when considering how you would like to use your soft dildo.

Oral and anal use are definitely not recommended for most soft dildos due to the potential for bacteria and fungus.

Depending on the material it is made out of, vaginal use may or may not be advised.

Sometimes, condoms should be used when performing vaginal penetration with these soft dildos.

While hard dildos provide a firm touch, many people prefer a soft, squishy feel.

Soft dildos are often widely liked for their realistic look and feel, makes them ideal for use with harnesses and packing to provide the illusion of a penis and/or “bulge”.

Review of the Best Soft Dildos

The main products we will be reviewing are soft dildos that are made to provide a realistic look and feel.

Many of these products are not advised for penetration as their primary function is for packing.

The main features of each product are talked about as well as the biggest pros and cons other users have experienced with these items.

1. Packer Gear Silicone Packing Penis 4 Inch

The Packer Gear Silicone Packing Penis 4 Inch provides the impressive realistic and is available in 4 skin tones. The entire thing is 5.5 inches long and 2.5 inches wide but the penis part itself is only 4 inches long and 1.5 inches wide. 

Its extremely soft, floppy and flexible to give the appearance of extreme well-endowment. It is comfortable enough for all day wear and made of silicone.

This dildo is not suitable for penetration but is excellent for play sword fighting and fondling. This product can be enjoyed on your own or with a partner as a nice addition to foreplay and sword-play.

It provides a good option for couples of all types, especially those who what to explore different gender options. Users especially enjoy this soft dildo for its realistic feel.


  • Body safe silicone material 
  • Waterproof
  • Great value
  • Realistic feel with balls
  • Comfortable for all day wear
  • Very floppy, squishy and flexible


  • Sticky feel
  • A bit small for some users. 

Bottom Line

This product is a great option if you want a smaller package with, with a variety of skin tones for added realism. 

Made from silicone for a great authentic feel, users were impressed by the soft and squishy feeling of this toy. 

2. Performance Packer 5 Inch Packing Dildo

Performance Packer 5 Inch Packing Dildo provides a soft dildo that offers a wide variety of sizes ranging from extra-small to large. This product is made to feel realistic, being composed of Fleshlight’s patented SuperSkin material.

Color options include Caramel, Flesh, and Pink. Mr. Limpy is made to be boasted as a lifelike package or a perfect addition to your bachelor/bachelorette party! This product is made from Fleshlight’s SuperSkin material which is a non-toxic, phthalate free, porous material.


  • Realistic
  • Fast shipping
  • Inexpensive
  • Size variability
  • Good for beginners


  • Sticky
  • Lack of durability
  • Larger than expected

Bottom Line

Buyers report this product to be a hit at parties as well as an overall good option for packing.Most say these dildos are much larger than expected and recommend purchasing a size down.

Some may have issues with this product’s durability but overall it’s a good option, especially for its price.

This packing penis by California Exotic Novelties proves to be very comfortable to wear and thanks to its squishy composure, provides a realistic feel.

Referred to as “the Goldilocks of soft cocks” customers rave about the size of this packing penis being just right.

This product has a specially designed base made to fit especially well in harnesses and packing it without a harness is not recommended. Made from “Pure Skin” material.


  • Real feel
  • Comfortable
  • Fast shipping
  • Sized perfectly
  • Discreet packaging


  • Few size/color options
  • Quality not suitable for frequent wear

Bottom Line

You don't have anything to worry about when receiving this product in the mail because it is delivered quickly in discreet packaging.

There are mixed reviews regarding its quality- many found it to be comfortable and realistic in both look and feel, while others report it not suitable for everyday wear due to issues with melting and tearing.

Although there does not seem to be a wide variety of color and size options, the majority of reviewers found this product to be sized perfectly.

This dildo is made of “Pure Skin” material, but little more can be found on the page about the type of material more specifically.

4. Doc Johnson - Pack It - Prosthetic Flaccid Penis

This product is extremely well priced and gives customers the option of two different sizes - lite and heavy. There is about an inch difference in the two sizes and three color variations.

It has veined detailing and can be worn with jockey shorts, jockstraps, and packing shorts. Many reviewers reported it was comfortable for all day wear. This product is meant for packing only and should not be used for penetration.

Shipment is also delivered in discreet packaging for privacy when purchasing. Also, this model is made of body-safe, phthalate free material.


  • Inexpensive
  • Realistic feel
  • Discreet packaging
  • Comfortable to wear


  • Poor quality
  • Harsh on skin
  • Not a natural looking bulge. Shaft is pretty erect

Bottom Line

While this product is inexpensive and boasts a realistic feel, many reviewers reported breaking out in rashes from wear, making this an unsuitable option for those with sensitive skin.

The biggest concern from users is this product’s poor quality, as many experienced tearing and melting after minimal use.

A strong vanilla/coconut smell was noted with this product, which seemed to be disliked by some while enjoyed by others. Overall, the price is great is it’s soft to the touch.

Made of solid silicone this packing dildo is made to be extremely durable while still providing the realistic feel people crave.

This material warms with your body heat to go the extra mile in providing the illusion of a real penis.

This product is made from hypoallergenic material and doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals like phthalates, jellies and latex.

It is dishwasher safe and easy to sterilize which is a huge plus considering the potential for bacteria with all soft dildos due to their porous.

This product is versatile in its wearibilty as it can be worn with a harness or fit into the front of men’s underwear.

This dildo is made from 100% hypoallergenic silicone that is free of phthaletes, latex and other harmful chemicals.


  • Slightly firm
  • Slightly firm
  • Excellent Quality
  • Retains body heat


  • Sticky
  • Larger than expected
  • Little on the pricier side

Bottom Line

This product is definitely one of the more expensive options when it comes to packing dildos, but you get what you pay for.

Made from high quality material it is safe and gentle on the skin while maintaining strong durability for heavy use.

One downside seemed to be its sticky feel, however buyers note it didn’t seem any stickier than most other soft dildos.

Many users say it is slightly larger than expected, and report it to be extremely comfortable, realistic, and flattering.

Types of Dildo Materials

Dildos typically fall into four main classes depending on the material they are made of: Silicone, Elastomer (TPR,TPE), Glass/metal/Ceramic, Jelly/PVC/cyberskin.

It is also important to note whether each material is porous vs. nonporous.

Why is this important?

Porous materials allow for things like bacteria and fungus to grow which can be very dangerous when coming into contact with some of your most “sensitive” areas.

Many products will be advertised as “body safe”.

Please be aware that this just means that the product is made without toxic chemicals such as phthalates, and does not identify whether or not the material is porous or not.

Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages and careful care and consideration should be taken when considering which material or type is right for you.

Elastomers such as TPR and TPE are polymer blends technically standing for thermoplastic rubber or thermoplastic elastomer.

These materials allow for the dildo to be flexible and affordable. This material should be washed with an antibacterial toy cleaner and kept somewhere where it can dry and breath.

These products are great for strap on and harness play, but caution should be taken when using vaginally as it is a porous material.

Thorough washing and condoms are highly recommended when using vaginally. Anal and/or oral use is definitely not recommended due to bacteria.

Glass, metal, and ceramic dildos are a hard material if you are looking for something with a firm touch. They are nonporous and safe for vaginal, oral, and anal use. They can also be used with harnesses but might require a special harness as they tend to be rather heavy.

Silicone tends to be the most popular material option for dildos because they provide a wide range of firmness, flexibility and prices. Silicone is nonporous and easily cleaned, therefore it can be used vaginally, anally, and orally.

There is a wide range of flexibility and firmness of silicone dildos. Hardness is measured in “shore durometer scales” which typically run form 0-100 (0 being extra soft, 100 being extra hard) and on three different scales: shore 00, shore A, and shore D.

When it comes to silicone dildos in particular, they are categorized into single-density silicone or dual-density dildos.

Dual density dildos are made up of a soft outer layer of silicone surrounding a firm inner core to mimic a more realistic penis.

They are soft and squishy to the feel but are unable to be bent backwards. Single-density dildos are just one layer of silicone of all the same firmness. Some are so soft they are able to be completely bent.

Lastly, there’s jelly/PVC/cyberskin. This material provides for a very flexible, soft feel; however, they are of porous material and difficult to thoroughly clean.

These toys should never be shared, or used orally or anally. Vaginal use is not recommended, but if it is used in this fashion condoms are extremely advised.

Predominant use of these dildos is for packing or strap-on and harness play due to their realistic look and feel.


There is a large array of dildos to choose from when purchasing your next toy. Variety in size, firmness, texture, material, and price are all aspects to take into consideration. It is very important to consider what you want to use this toy for as the dildo’s material will play a large role in its use.

Hard dildos provide a firm experience, while soft dildos are much more flexible and squishy. This makes them popular for wearing, to give the look of a real penis. Soft dildos and packers in particular can be made from a variety of materials which can be very important for things like durability and comfort for all day wear.

We hope this review article of the best soft dildos has been helping in narrowing down your next toy. If something stood out to you or you have some first hand experience to report, be sure to drop a comment below. We love hearing from readers and look forward to what you have to say!

If you would like to browse a large selection of soft dildos or "packers" we recommend you visit Betty's Toy Box for their excellent products and wonderful customer service. 

Leave a Comment